The End of Erdogan

16th March 2014 – By Henri J. Barkey. It is hard to imagine how in any society a Prime Minister caught on tape firing journalists because he does not like their point of view or instructing television stations to stop the broadcasting of an opposition leader’s speech in parliament could survive. And this is only the tip of the iceberg of corruption allegations that have been leveled at this particular PM’s ministers, their families, and most critically at him and his own son.

Welcome to Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s Turkey. While he’s indirectly conceded the interference with the freedom of the press, the Prime Minister and his stalwarts have engaged in a scorched-earth strategy of blaming a vast conspiracy for the attacks against him. Never mind that ministers have lost their jobs and their sons have been arrested (along with a state-owned bank CEO). Never mind the millions of dollars worth of cash found in houses owned by all these figures, or the taped conversations leaked to the public, mainly through social media outlets, revealing that judicial investigations have been ongoing for sometime. Forget all that: It is not the alleged thieves, crooks, and their enablers who are at fault, but the accusers. So goes the logic in Erdogan’s Turkey. There’s nothing wrong with having millions of dollars and euros stashed at your home or office or elsewhere, and sweetheart deals with shady businessmen are perfectly okay. It’s questioning these practices that is the real threat to the nation.

At the heart of the conspiracy, it is claimed, is a “parallel state” led by Fethullah Gulen, a reclusive cleric who sought refuge in the United States in 1999 when he was persecuted by the then-dominant Turkish military establishment. Gulen and Erdogan had earlier formed an alliance against this common enemy. But now, with the military forced back into its barracks, they have turned on each other. For Erdogan and his supporters this vast conspiracy, instigated by Gulen and his presumed followers in the judiciary and the police force, is aided and abetted by a slew of villains. These include, Americans, Jews, Israel, Germans, neocons, CNN, Financial Times, a variety of international and domestic banks, the Council on Foreign Relations. Even the Queen of England, if you can believe it, has nothing better to do with her time than plot the downfall of the Turkish Prime Minister and his supporters. Why, exactly, would all these people have it in for Erdogan? It’s a mystery, of course.

But let’s set aside these fantasies, at long last. The truth is that Erdogan is the principal and lead actor in his own demise. As good a politician he has been up to recent times, these allegations somehow caught him by surprise. He has been the unchallenged leader of Turkey for a decade. No one has dared cross him, and no one has figured out how to beat him. The opposition has been weak, and the resources he has marshaled have enabled him and his party, the Justice and Development Party, AKP, to build a formidable patronage network that encompasses a vast segment of the Turkish press, business groups, lots of NGOs, think tanks, and segments of the bureaucracy. The money that he and his family members have allegedly collected has not merely gone toward self-enrichment, but also toward financing and building a monumental network of individuals and organizations whose only loyalty is to Erdogan.

Continuous: http://www.the-american-interest.com/articles/2014/03/13/the-end-of-erdogan/

Facebook digitocides against the opposition in Turkey

Some weeks ago, the Minister of Transportation, Binali Yildirim had announced that Twitter did not respond positively to a “cooperation” agreement to determine and spot those who get involved in criminal activities through expressing their views online, while Facebook seemed to cooperate.

Following the agreement, important opposition pages such as citizen-journalism, leftist, Kurdish, Alevi religious or LGBT pages were closed down on Facebook for no valid or irrelevant reasoning (some of the news sources’ closing down reason was stated that they share pornographic content), together with dozens of pages which reflect an alternative to government’s rhetoric on the internet.

In order to protest this process of silencing down opposition voices on Facebook, many users have been involved in a series of digital protests mainly involving twitter hashtags, penguin spamming (of Facebook’s official page), ad boycotting, and lastly a 24 hour account deactivation boycott on 21st of July. Even after these Facebook does not seem to have heard the voice of Turkish opposition and repeatedly closes down reserve pages of the same titles (which used to have hundreds of thousands of followers), this time not even giving a reason.

The government-leaning hackers have been bombarding the social media platforms through use of excessive number of fake accounts, organizing spam-attacks and filing complaint reports about opposition pages stating that they are promoting sexual content. As Facebook has been avoiding any involvement in fighting hate speech and instigation to violence on hate groups, it actually now contributes to the ongoing digitocide happening in cyber-lands of Gezi Park.

Among the pages that have been closed down are Ötekilerin Postasi (the biggest citizen journalism platform in Turkey that has broken the news of many big events that mainstream media shunned from covering), DurDe (an unofficial NGO that aims to prevent hate speech and hate crimes), BDP (one of the parliamentary parties, representing mainly the Kurdish population in the country), Carsi (football fans of mainly Besiktas). All these groups and pages in total welcomed millions of users who do not give up and continue to “like” the new pages.

The original source: http://radicaldemocrat.blog.com/2013/07/30/digitocide/

Petition to BBC to drop NTV

http://www.change.org/petitions/bbc-please-stop-your-partnership-with-biased-ntv-news-in-turkey#

We call on the BBC to protect its reputation for impartiality by suspending its partnership with NTV in Turkey and to refer the partnership to the BBC Trust to consider its permanent cancellation.

NOTES:

NTV has admitted that its lack of coverage of the outbreak of large scale and unprecedented protests in the centre of Turkey’s largest city was in direct response to political pressure.

And the BBC’s own coverage says NTV has “steered clear of covering the demonstrations” and is “loth to irritate the government because their owners’ business interests at times rely on government support.”

The BBC guidelines clearly state: “Any external relationship must not undermine the BBC’s core values of impartiality, editorial integrity, and independence.”

Same old same old from the PM of Turkey

For Turkish see: http://www.radikal.com.tr/politika/basbakan_erdogan_topcu_kislasini_yapiyoruz-1136521

PM Recep Tayyip Erdogan talked about the events in Turkey on the last day of his visit to Tunisia. He said the Topcu Barrack [on Gezi Park] will be built and that protestors are damaging public’s buses and pavement stones. He gave the following answers to the questions in his press conference.

Q: Do you support your Deputy Bülent Arınç’s statement yesterday?

[translator’s note: we can loosely say that BA had apologised for the violence]

A: My deputy has done what’s necessary. What we say is clear. We conduct politics on the basis that we will not humour these nor deceive. All actions progress in this context. But they say these things. It’s not necessary to get into this kind of a race. Government cannot be managed by the logic of give and take. Is there a Topcu Barracks there or not? We are not promising something that wasn’t there….We are rebuilding what was there. We want to repeat a fantastic architectural asset. Wherever you go in the world, such historial sites are rebuilt and people would be proud of this. Why are they opposing it because the AKP government is doing this? We had shown it to Istanbul as a new innovative project with animations. They don’t mention this at all. They now do these things. We will work with the same environmental consciousness in Taksim. Environment is a holistic thing, not just a tree. They are pulling the roads, pavement stones. We need to investigate the damage done to people’s buses and bus stops. We need to see who joined in the ranks of my sincere citizens. I am inviting these citizens to protect the country and the environment.
Q: Your deputy apologised for the use of excessive force. Do you accept this? Will you be opening the door to dialogue with the protesters?
A: Dear friends, my deputy made all the necessary statements. You of course can’t follow us. If this is to do with overuse of gas, we’ve expressed our sadness about that. We don’t need to repeat this again. There is nowhere in the world, including the developed countries, that does not use tear gas. There can be nothing out of law. If you are going to have a meeting, there are places for that. You go there. If you are going to do a demonstration, you can demonstrate there too. But if you say I demonstrate wherever I want, I burn, I break, this will not be allowed.

We are a party that got 21.5 million votes. We faced close down. We didn’t let our constituency to take to the streets then. We fought democratically, then the law decided. And gave us what was rightly ours. It was in favour of us. I am telling you openly and clearly. We are against the majority dominating the minority. However, we will definitely not tolerate the minority dominating the majority. You need to know that the best thing to do is to protect the rule of law. We also need to protect the natural beauty of Istanbul.

Translator’s note on the context: the population of Turkey is almost 76 million people.  Several experts have been opposing the plans for the barracks since the beginning and their comments have not been taken into account. In modern democracies tear gas may be used as a last resort. At least to our knowledge in the UK, stationary protests do not require permission, while marches need permission but, with the exception of around the Parliament, they can take place anywhere.

“A democracy is nothing more than mob rule, where fifty-one percent of the people may take away the rights of the other forty-nine.”
― Thomas Jefferson

http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/tag/majority

Peace!